You know, there are a lot of voices out there that will say Israel is committing genocide in Gaza. You hear it on the news, you hear it on social media, and you hear it from celebrities. Israel is constantly maligned and attacked. But is it true? The short answer is no. The reality is, Israel is the underdog in all this. They are held to a double standard that no other country is held to. They are the only country that is vilified for defending itself and called genocidal when they do. You won’t hear that accusation in the Russian-Ukraine war or any other conflict. Of all the countries in the world, Israel is the only one that gets that ignominious label.
So, let’s get into it. In any discussion or debate, it’s important to ask questions. My first question is, what makes it a genocide? It has never been the policy of Israel to intentionally target civilians. In fact, they have gone out of their way to avoid civilian casualties. I’ll give an example from Israel’s previous conflicts. During Operation Cast Lead in 2008, Israel used guided bombs filled not with explosives but with cement. This was done because it still did damage to the target, but it minimized damage to the surrounding civilian populace. Another thing Israel does is warn civilians prior to an attack by making phone calls, sending texts, and even dropping pamphlets and leaflets. This is often to their own detriment because it also tips off their hand to their enemies.
If Israel’s true goal was genocide, they could have done so a long time ago and without much difficulty. In any war, civilians are going to get killed. That’s just the reality of the situation. But for anyone who thinks Israel's response is somehow disproportionate, they are being unrealistic. I can’t think of a single country that would be okay if terrorists came into their country, killed their civilians, and took hostages. Any country on the planet would respond with overwhelming force if that happened to them.
Now, let’s talk about the Palestinians and HAMAS, as they are both culpable in what is happening now. In 2005, Israel unilaterally withdrew from the Gaza Strip, even forcibly removing Israeli settlers in the process. At that point, Gaza was “free” and semi-autonomous (I say semi because they were and still are heavily dependent on Israel to function). So, what is the first thing the Palestinians do? They elected Hamas, a terrorist organization, to govern the Palestinian Authority. And what is the first thing that Hamas did? They fired thousands of rockets into Israel. Thus began a repeated cycle of attacks on Israel followed by military operations to end hostilities. Since 2005, Israel has been in seven major conflicts in the Gaza Strip. This, of course, culminated in the October 7th massacre in 2023.
You see, unlike Israel, Hamas actually does target civilians, and they’re not above using their own civilians as meat shields. It is well documented that Hamas routinely uses places like schools and hospitals to either launch their attacks or as a base of operations. They do this for two reasons. For one, they hope to deter or minimize any sort of Israeli counterattack. And two, when civilians die, it actually helps them, and that is what this is really about. Hamas knows they can never beat Israel militarily. They also know the West is sensitive to civilian casualties. The more civilians that die, the better it is for them. It’s the only way they can win. So, they use civilian deaths as part of their propaganda war against Israel. It’s a military strategy and one that many have unwittingly adopted.
The Palestinians themselves are also not guilt-free. Remember, it is they who elected Hamas in the first place. Let’s talk about some other things the Palestinians have done. Palestinians cheered in the streets when America was attacked on 9/11. Many hostages from the October 7th attack were held in Palestinian homes. According to the Arab World for Research and Development (AWRAD) survey*, 75% of Palestinians supported the October 7 massacre, and 85.9% reject coexistence with Israel. 74.7% support the creation of a Palestinian state “from the river to the sea,” which is itself a genocidal statement and one that has been adopted by useful idiots in the West. Everyone who uses that slogan decries one “genocide” by instigating another.
These are the type of people that those in the West are supporting. Palestinians are among the most radicalized people in that region, which is why no other country wants to take them in. Gaza and the Palestinians are in the state that they are in because of their continual refusal to live in peace with Israel. All their resources are put into fighting Israel. And guess what? Hamas and their Arab and Iranian allies want it that way. They don’t want conditions in Gaza to improve, because then they couldn’t use the Palestinians as a thorn in Israel’s side. They would rather have Palestinians used as political pawns. As a result, continual conflict is guaranteed, as well as deteriorating conditions in Gaza and an ever-increasing radicalization of Palestinian youths to perpetuate the endless cycle. There is a saying, “If the Palestinians put down their weapons, there would be peace; if Israel put down its weapons, there would be no more Israel.”
Let’s also get another thing clear: Palestinians are largely an invented people. They have no unique ethnic identity or language of their own. They are a hodgepodge of mostly Arab ethnicities. Incidentally, they share quite a bit of DNA with Jews. Palestine referred to a province of the Ottoman Empire. It wasn’t a people; it was a geographical region. For a time, prior to World War 1, even Jews referred to themselves as Palestinians the same way someone would refer to where they lived, regardless of their ethnicity. It really wasn’t until the 1960s when Yasser Arafat created the Palestinian identity and turned the issue into a human rights struggle.
Since I’m on the topic, let’s talk about whose land it belongs to. That little piece of contested land has changed hands many, many times during the past three millennia. At the turn of the 20th century, it was under the control of the Ottoman Turks. They sided with the Central Powers during World War I and lost. As a result, they lost control of their land. It then came under the control of the British in 1920. The Mandate for Palestine ended in 1948, at which point the land was essentially up for grabs. The Jews and Arabs immediately went to war over it, and the Jews won. It now belongs to Israel for that very reason. Land, any land, belongs to those who can occupy it and defend it, period. Every nation on earth exists because they fought someone else for it and won. I would add that after World War I, several empires collapsed, and many nation-states were created, including Iraq, Transjordan (now Jordan), Syria, and Lebanon. So, Israel was not unique in that regard.
*Source: https://jcpa.org/a-new-poll-of-palestinians-supporting-terror-and-rejecting-peace/